Author Topic: Merilyn Tunneshende  (Read 10270 times)

Bendigeidfran

  • Guest
Merilyn Tunneshende
« on: December 04, 2005, 06:40:58 am »
Does anyone know anything about this person. She's written a lot of books, and claims to be a Nagual.

I've read that she was associated with Castaneda, and also claims that she met and spent time with  don Juan before he died, reputedly in 1991.

Sounds dodgy to me, as I have never bought into the whole Castaneda thing - far too weird and New Age for me!  However, a close friend seems to be swallowing both her and Taisha Abelar wholesale, and believing it.  (And Amazon making a bit of profit too, of course)

Any information would be much appreciated.

Offline educatedindian

  • Administrator
  • *****
  • Posts: 4772
Re: Merilyn Tunneshende
« Reply #1 on: December 20, 2005, 09:28:25 pm »
Sorry for overlooking this one. It's kind of hard to know what to answer. MT claimed in her books to know the "real" teacher of Castaneda, and claimed Casteneda was a fraud. So the Castaneda fanatics hate her like no other on the planet, while at the same time she has a small following gathered from within their ranks.

In other words, a fraud preying on a fraud, using techniques and tactics much like the original fraud. In some sense, it's ironic justice. But then again, I don't know what proof your friend would accept. After all, in the other thread, you said direct evidence, like testimony from Casteneda's own inner circle, was not good enough for you.

I don't know, short of Castaneda coming back from the dead and admitting he was a fraud, what would make your friend listen.

After all, Castaneda was debunked as a fraud by Natives immediately, and by anthropologists about five years later. And then he began openly admitting he was a fraud for the entire rest of his life, throwing it in his followers' faces and treating them with more and more contempt. But castaneda cultists claim truth doesn't matter, proof doesn't matter, etc. It's a nice scam, where wishful thinking is all that matters.