... is it really that unreasonable to ask lodge attendees to help cover the expenses incurred by the leader? Are you saying that everything including meals should be free before it can be considered legitimate, or is it that $50 is too much? Is there a rule of thumb for pricing on things like this?
Thanks
Jim
YES! In my experience many groups hide behind the use of the term "donation". Its it what is used to lend credibility to what they are stealing. There are many MANY whack jobs that openly charge for sacred ceremonies. What is even more sad is the fact that wounded people and misinformed people will throw money at these Plastic Shamans. The next group of pretendians try to differentiate themselves from the nuage huxters by pointing to the fact they do not charge for ceremony. This becomes important when people within the group begin to question if it is ok. The people you have inquired about in the DFW area are frauds. Neither person is Lakota. A non-lakota performing a ceremony (free, donations, or charged for) is wrong. It is stealing the culture of the Lakota people.
If you bring this to their attention, (especially Randy Parsons) you will get a lecture on lineage. Randy is now a "Chief". He was made one by Chief Leonard Crow Dog. That is credible, right? Wrong. Chief of what? What is a white guy going to do with a bonnet? Who are his "people". Leonard is famous for making white people chiefs. But wait, there is more! Randy has been a Sun Dancer for 15 years.(Granted, it was in TX and the Sun Dance Chief is a white guy) He had a teach, Chira Sweet Medicine! Chira Sweet Medicine had a teacher- Mary Thunder. And Mary Thunder's teacher was Leonard Crow Dog. That is the justification presented to new people that would (correctly) question what they had encountered.
Next, you will be given the teachings about how the ceremony is kept pure. From teacher to teacher, nothing is ever added to, or taken away from the ceremony. That Randy does it just as he was taught all the way back to the Lakotas. It is filed under, "Original instructions."
You may ask how I know about these things. I was a member of Randy's group for 10 years. I spent years questioning internally. I broke away last year. They didn't try to chase me down and drag me back. I was arrogantly waved off as "less than" and foolish. I strongly suggest you stay away from that group. They mean well, but create more harm than good.
You are cherokee. If you want to learn go to your people. I say that with sincerity. You are not Lakota, and I don't think you would want to learn Lakota things from a 60 something year old white guy with a counseling degree.
Roy
aka used2bnaf
Former adopted son of Chief Crow (Randy Parsons)