"For the most part, I don't see anything that refutes what I earlier said about your group:"
As I stated in my earlier response, it is not my group, I am not a member. I do know members, and I know their ultimate goal is to do good.
"I think the leaders of your group are a mix of the blind leading the blind, and the half blind trying to fleece the completely blind."
Once again, they are not my group, I was only offering a bit more information based on my own research of the group. I believe that you are ascribing intentions without knowing their true intentions by using the term fleece. I have seen no efforts to entice people to pay beyond asking for the donation to cover the cost of printing membership cards. If they were asking hundreds of dollars, maybe then I would say fleece also, but they are asking a nominal fee.
You could claim your heritage, but none of what you are doing is part of it. Hiding behind "I want my heritage" doesn't make taking people's money, or asking for information that could only be used for wrong, any less wrong thing to do. Your actions are wasichu, not Cherokee or NDN. For so called chiefs, you don't have much knowledge. You are doing things even your average NDN child knows are wrong.
The right way to claim your heritage would be to go to actual Cherokee and listen and learn, not try to set up a phony "tribe" with phony "clans."
Once again, I am not Tsalagi, nor do I play one in real life. I am learning as I go about many cultures in an effort to learn, understand, and remove ignorance. If I demanding my "heritage" it would be Huron if my aunts findings are true. But then again, I did a cursory search and found no evidence to back up my aunts assertions, so I have let it be. Though I found the Wendat in Quebec to be much more helpful on my path than the stories I have heard from Cherokees seeking to reconnect. You say that they should go to an actual Cherokee and listen and learn. I have heard from many who have tried and been turned away. One woman had contacted the Eastern band and was told "Yeah, yeah, everyone has a g-g-grandmother who was a Cherokee Princess" and hung up on. She never mentioned anything about Cherokee Princess, yet the assumption was made and she was dismissed. I have heard many other stories like this from people who have found that their heritage had been hidden from them by their ancestors due to Indian Schools, hiding amongst the whites so as not to be relocated from their homes, etc. As they are finding their roots, they wish to learn and are being turned away.
"But some of what I said I was glad you had enough courage to be honest about the wrongness some leaders were doing:"
I never said they were wrong, simply that they are stumbling along, trying to find their way. Their hearts appear good, but they need better organizational skills."
"Could you tell us this leader's actual name was?"
I thought I did, but maybe not, Chief Speaks With Spirits Name is Angie Rose.
"This next part, though, had a bit of persecution complex common to many PODIAs:
"John Ross, Quannah Parker, and of course, Will Thomas would never have become the great leaders."
Are you kidding? There are probably more mixedblood leaders elected to office than fullbloods. Certainly that was true immediately after the IRA govts were first set up. Nearly all of that first wave of IRA govts were mixedblood led.
And plenty of non-NDNs are respected for their help to NDNs."
I don't think it is persecution, I merely was pointing out that throughout Tsalagi history, some whites have been seen as brothers. You were the one who attacked Bear Warrior for being half Puerto Rican.
"I think most of us, and most NDNs in general, would agree with your point about the disenrollment happening in some tribal nations. Where we strongly disagree is that a group passing itself off as a "tribe" is the solution."
I don't believe they have passed themselves off as a Tribe. They call the state groups clans, yes, but they never claimed to be a separate tribe. And yes, they use the title Chief for the leaders of the state groups/clans. Once again, though, they have never said they were a separate Tribe.
"Some of what you believe shows Nuage influence whether you realize it or not:"
Not all New Age is bad. And yes, I have many influences as I have studied Buddhism, Hindu, and the healing arts of our Asian brothers and sisters. I have also studied some Black medicine ways such as the Healing Drums of the Minianka of Mali. I have studied of the ways of the Aztec Curandero which is a blending of Native, African, and Spanish medicine. I have studied Medicine ways of Native Americans and the healing herbs that are available to me locally. I have studied the ways of the shaman of Europe and other countries. Why have I done this? Because of something I read about bringing the wisdom of the colors together. The only way to do this is to remove the ignorance and walk with no preconceived notions. I have seen the benefits of yoga, Reiki, and even aroma therapy. I don't dismiss them simply because they are New Age. I actually hate that term as it has become prejudicial. I hear many Native Americans spit the word out as if it were bile. Yet, in truth, those who truly follow these beliefs and are not out to take advantage of others have great hearts and wish only to bring healing. If you researched, you would find that many New Age beliefs and healing arts have ancient beginnings. So the whole idea of it being New is a misnomer. It is a rediscovery. I am not a New Ager, only a learner. I walk with an open heart and try not to judge. In this way, I have learned a great deal that may be needed in the years to come.
"I have read many of the prophesies and they all say that now is the time. The Mayan Calendar is pointing to 2012. Science is backing that up in that it is predicted that the sun will be going solar maximum at that time. It may be worsened with the position of the earth on the equator of the galaxy. Instead of bickering over whose way is better, or more right, maybe we should be looking at ways to bring all people together"
I can almost hear "Kum Bay Yah" being sung in the background."
Why do you feel the need to be derogatory? What is wrong with trying to bring the people together?
"Many of those prophecies you read are false, Nuage distortions. The Mayan calendar just ends in 2012. It doesn't predict disaster. In fact it doesn't say anything. It was just a randomly chosen point to end at."
Hmmm, yes, in my prayers once I asked, what is the truth? I was told, "If I gave you the truth, you wouldn't have the journey". Maybe the Hopi Bear Clan Prophecy is false, I have read that Rainbow Eagle's Anishinabe Peace Shield is. I have heard prophesies from the Apache from Apaches. Maybe they are lying to me too. Maybe the whole world is a lie. Maybe you have lied. I don't know. It is hard to know what to believe in this world anymore. I have been told many things from Native Americans. Are they all lies? I have stated that the Mayan Calendar may be just another Millenium and that the clock will tick over and everything will just continue on. However, there has been research done that shows patterns that align with the Mayan Calendar and the "predictions". One of these researchers, a man named Calleman, actually states that things will come to a head in Oct of 2011, not 21 Dec 2012. I would have to read more, as I only read one book on this so as to become more familiar with what people are talking about. Once again, reading to try to remove ignorance. I have stacks of books covering all kinds of subjects, usually reading two or three at a time and following it up with online research. Knowledge removes ignorance and brings us closer as we remove the barriers of understanding.
And the sun going "solar maximum?
I believe someone else all ready responded. From what I gather, it is a cycle that has been going on for a great many years. The cycle is about eleven years in length going from solar minimum where there is little solar activity to solar maximum where there is increased activity. This activity causes a reaction on the earth. It could manifest as more storms, more severe storms, even earthquakes. Of course, events here on earth also effect the sun as we are in a symbionic relationship. Scientists are currently analyzing the anomoly of 2005 that brought us higher solar activity than predicted and Hurricane Katrina. There is a lot more, if you are interested, but I think this is getting a bit off topic.